Saturday, July 11, 2009

Bruno: Delicious Journeys Through America for the Purpose of Making Heterosexual Males Visibly Uncomfortable in the Presence of a Gay Foreigner in...


...a Mesh T-Shirt

If only that were the real title.

So I belong to an intellectual elite of people who consider Borat a modern comic masterpiece. Also, I'm a huge fan of Da Ali G Show and Sacha Baron Cohen in general. How many other entertainers are willing to put their life on the line or go to any of the extremes he does for their art? Not many. And how many of these people turn out to be using these elaborate schemes to veil their lack of talent? Many.

It thus disheartens me to say that Bruno is something of a disappointment. Not that it isn't funny, for I laughed many times. More times, in fact, than many recent comedies. But it doesn't work as a film. But, as always, I'm getting ahead of myself.

For those of you who don't know, Bruno is a character that Sacha Baron Cohen used on Da Ali G Show, the same show that gave birth to the Borat character. Bruno is a homosexual Austrian fashion expert whose main purpose as a satire is to lampoon homophobes and the vanity of the fashion world.

That's a very specific vein to spike, unlike in Borat where the target of the satire was simply "America's differing attitudes towards foreigners". While there's an incredibly deep well to draw from there with shocking revelations of how Cohen can get these people to act, Bruno is a far shallower character.

Any half-way intelligent person already knows that homophobes are stupid and that the fashion industry is completely vacuous and self-important, so nothing is revelatory. Mostly Cohen winds people up for the sake of winding them up, and it makes the whole act completely transparent.

At the same time, people have much less patience for a flamboyant fashionista that offends them at every turn than for a loveabley confused foreigner who doesn't seem to grasp the niceties of western culture. And I mean a LOT less patience. It's actually the film's biggest problem. None of the situations last long enough to make an impact and none of the things he manages to get out of the people he's talking to are very good. They don't reveal anything to this character because they don't trust him and he's simply an offensive stereotype. For instance, there's a scene where Bruno interviews a real, live terrorist, but the scene ends far too soon when the terrorist becomes offended.

But this scene is a perfect description of everything that is good and bad about this film, so let's take a look at it.



That scene lasts forty seconds. In it, Cohen manages to make one joke. And it's a very funny joke, but he doesn't get anything out of the terrorist. The terrorist merely becomes offended and kicks him out. It actually smells like failure. Performing this style of guerrilla comedy, you want reactions out of the people you're interviewing, and when you don't get a reaction, you've failed. Essentially this whole movie is Sacha Baron Cohen being funny, but no one else going along for the ride.

It's a shame because Cohen is clearly giving it his all, but the Bruno character just doesn't work as well as the Borat character.

Cohen could have great luck as a serious actor or as a comic actor. I really hope for the best for him, but I think that this sort of film is over. I don't think it will ever work as well as Borat, and while Bruno is a nice effort, it simply doesn't work. It can't work.

5/10

9 comments:

NFB said...

Did Twitter kill Bruno?

http://www.time.com/time/arts/article/0,8599,1910059,00.html?xid=rss-topstories

Oliver said...

All I've heard from people complaining about the film is how gay it was. I heard a group of people talking about it when I left the theater, and one of my friends went to see it and heard a group of girls talking about what a fag he was and how disgusted they were by the whole movie. I think people just didn't think (with their brains, anyway) about what this movie would be about. Apparently the "gay" part of the plot was left out to the entire world's population.

This is the sort of thing that will make me more defensive of a film. I really can't figure out why homophobia is still an issue.

The only thing I've ever had a problem with was when I went to gay pride and all the women were incredibly cold to my advances.

NFB said...

Not only did they not pay any attention to the pre-release publicity they must not have looked at the poster while standing in the box office line. It is amazing how out of it a lot of people are.

Oliver said...

And the studio blew $100 million on the project for no damn reason.

Devin D said...

I did not like Bruno very much at all. Sure, I sound myself - periodically, mind you - in stitches, but come on...

My quick two cents can be found here: closelywatchingfilm.blogspot.com

Oliver said...

I just think it's unfair to compare this film to Borat. It was never going to be Borat and I think that Cohen did the best he could.

NFB said...

Meanwhile the new Harry Potter movies appears to have set an all time record for midnight preview screening. From IMDB:

Harry Potter And The Half-Blood Prince Smashes Preview Records

15 July 2009 11:43 AM, PDT


Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince smashed preview records at its midnight opening Wednesday as it raked in $22.2 million -- coming in far ahead of the previous record holder, last year’s The Dark Knight, which took in $18.5 million during previews, Warner Bros. said today (Wednesday). The studio released both movies. Earlier, box-office analysts predicted that the movie would likely earn $140 million or more between Wednesday and Sunday, with $100 million being tallied over the Friday-to-Sunday weekend. But such figures now appear to be conservative. In fact, today’s Hollywood Reporter indicated that the film has a realistic shot of outdoing The Dark Knight, which earned $158.3 million during its opening weekend a year ago. (The trade publication noted that advance ticket sales for the movie continue to outpace those for Knight.) The Potter sequel also faces little competition, with no other film opening wide this weekend. “And the most prominent second-weekend holdover -- Universal’s R-rated comedy BrĂ¼no -- couldn’t have a more distinct target audience from that of Prince,” THR observed.

Oliver said...

I'm just glad that Transformers 2 isn't going to be the highest grossing film of the year.

NFB said...

Let's hope not.